Plans for National Infrastructure Commission independence watered down | EEF

Plans for National Infrastructure Commission independence watered down

Subscribe to Campaigning blog feeds


A new government inevitably comes with new priorities and in the area of infrastructure, this is no different. Infrastructure is a critical issue for manufacturers in the UK and infrastructure provision has been worsening in key areas.

To address this the previous government had agreed to set up a National Infrastructure Commission (NIC) however over the summer the government decided to drop proposals to create the NIC from the Neighbourhood Planning and Infrastructure Bill, the Bill thus became simply the Neighbourhood Planning Bill.

For proponents of the NIC, such as EEF, this was a backward step – however the government promised it was simply under review and they would come forward with alternative proposals.

This week, they published those proposals. Promising ‘permanence’ and ‘independence’, however scratch beneath the surface and those words deflect from the fact that by setting the NIC up as an executive agency it delivers less certainty on permanence and independence compared to the promised alternative of statutory underpinning through an Act of Parliament.

The executive agency route provides less indepedence

Executive agencies, such as the DVLA or VOA, are typically bodies that deliver on government policy or provide an arm’s length service.

The ambition behind the NIC was different – an early warning system on infrastructure challenges to allow a debate to take place on which ones are the most crucial the potential alternatives and the economic, environmental and social cost of not doing nothing.

This last aspect, the cost of doing nothing, was why independence and transparency is so crucial to the NIC – as invariably, it is governments who tend to prevaricate on doing something.

An executive agency, without statutory underpinning, is independent purely if it enjoys political backing. While this may seem like a technical point, in essence the government can simply shut up shop at any point in time or change the NIC’s remit.

Over time we hope the government recognises the value of true independence for the NIC and builds on this week’s announcement to give it the permanence and independence in legislation that such a crucial function deserves.


This person has now left EEF. Please contact us on 0808 168 1874 or email us at if you have any questions.

Other articles from this author >
fact-card-thumbnail UK Manufacturing Facts, 2018/19

See our latest facts and figures on how manufacturing is contributing to the UK economy.

Read more >
MOTH spotlight Listen to 'Manufacturing on the hop'

Get the latest on the state of the manufacturing industry in this regular podcast with EEF Chief Economist Lee Hopley.

Listen now>
Online payments are not supported by your browser. Please choose an alternative browser or make payments through the 'Other payment options' on step 3.